In March he took a three week trip and I knew things were not the same. I drove him home the night he returned and stood outside the building, trying to remember the exact moment they’ve begun to change. I thought maybe we could pass through this, all couples must.
Can you return the books you took out last week?
Aren’t you heading out there anyway? Can’t you pass by the library on your way back?
Another Sunday afternoon and another Sunday afternoon fight. Statements turned into questions. Sometimes confrontational and accusatory, most times phrased in the negative. The slow dance of love, laughter, and taking care of each other seemed to fade into the background, replaced by short, impatient exchanges. It was not only the words that seemed to fail us. We could not say much of what we felt and thought. Rather than comfort, a touch or a hand holding was desperate and frantic.
I think of the bonds we form with one another as invisible bursts of light. When you disclose something of yourself, say a kind word, or help with a difficult problem, you throw a burst of light at the other person and an invisible bond is formed. Through these arguments, not only were bonds not formed but old ones began to strain under the resentment. And I knew clearly that I was the reason and the agent.
I woke up every morning with a resolution to stop and do better. I had to recover from this madness. I shut my eyes tightly before picking up the cell phone, breathe deeply and hope that my old voice would be back. That our old talks would be back. The phone stops ringing and a short, impatient exchange would end too soon.
Time for reflection and eventual understanding can run out on you quickly. I didn’t understand it completely at the time but I couldn’t reconcile my desire for a new life with a wish for family acceptance. I made a choice. I couldn’t marry without my father’s approval, blessings, and engagement, none of which he was willing to give. And I wanted all of them with not one left behind. Inflexibility must be where the unwise live. I was too much of a coward to see what the other side of the mountain held for me*.
That time should have been a time to make sense of the stresses of a new life and the weight of possibilities. I should have been concerned with the home and family we were about to build. Instead, we were mired in a hideous emotional battle that neither of us knew how to navigate.
My father had his reasons. What being cut off really meant in a day-to-day sense of the phrase remains a mystery; in other words, I don’t know what fathers did when they cut off their daughters. As with delayed understanding, there was really no choice that needed to be made. A father can no more sever a grown daughter from his life than he can will her unborn.
I don’t know what the greater tragedy is, that we deny one another a chance at happiness or that we give up on whom we love so easily.
With a luxury of a postmortem on a postmortem, I ask myself about what I had lost. I had lost a home I would build with a man who loved me and I loved him. I had lost a family of my own that would expand the one from which I had grown. Every once in a while I would tell myself that a long, happy marriage is near extinction and ask myself if I really thought anything that good lasted in life. I had lost my closest confidante, the person whom I’ve called whenever something exciting, frightening, or hilarious passed through my day. What have I gained? I’d lie to you if I said I’d gained anything.
Several months after we had last spoken, I celebrated my birthday with a number of friends and he showed up near the end of the night with an invitation to have dinner before his departure the following week. His work has since taken him to another state. He knew I hated surprises and apologized but I was genuinely delighted to see his face. The dinner was not as awkward as I had feared. It was quite lovely actually. We had a great deal of catching up to do about work, family, and mutual friends that either he or I had not seen much of, depending on who introduced whom. Sometime near the end of the night, I don’t remember what words were said, but I was overwhelmed with the greatest feeling of sadness. It was as though my chest was carved out. He meant the world to me and yet we were sitting facing one another and neither had the will nor the ability to say anything.
In the months prior to this last meeting, I’ve felt all types of regret. Dull, aching regrets and burning, stabbing regrets. For all this pain, things do get better. There are days and sometimes weeks that pass that I don’t remember the pain. Regrets are another story. It has been a few years now and a great part of my sanity is back as I no longer bury myself in work. I have also taken some steps towards a different life altogether. Better late than never, right?
* A mentor and a friend often told me a story of a wise ancient Egyptian who enlightens a boy with the understanding that he has seen more than his grandfather and knows more than his father. And rather than believe what others tell him is on the other side of the mountain, to climb it and see for himself.


